Russians Think We’re Engaging in Olympic Schadenfreude. They’re Right. By Julia Ioffe. The New Republic, February 6, 2014.
Ioffe:
As
Western journalists have flooded into Sochi for the 2014 Winter Olympics, they
have taken to Twitter to howl about the state of disarray in their hotel rooms.
The curtains are broken, the elevators are breaking, the pillows are deficit goods, the water is yellow and cold, and it’s all an unmitigated clusterfuck.
And the
Russians have had enough. Noting that the lead-up to the Olympics was full of
negative cover stories on Russia—like the Economist’s
and, well, ours—Vladimir Yakunin, the head of the Russian rail monopoly,
slammed Western journalists for “feeding hysteria about Russia.” And he’s not
just bothered by the images of Putin on the covers that upset him, or the
stories of mind-boggling corruption, or the warnings of “black widows” and “creating
fears that the Games in Sochi will not have adequate security.” It’s the vocal,
ungrateful complaining about Sochi’s readiness, “which takes the form of
mockery worthy of tabloids and not serious journalists.” “They are sending their readers signals that
are far from sportsmanlike, and the tone they take with the country hosting the
Olympics is far from friendly,” Yakunin writes. “Really, this has nothing to do
with freedom of speech. Rather, it is a desire to befoul everything about the
massive effort to prepare for the Winter Games, and to create a negative
atmosphere for the athletes and Olympic guests.”
Now,
Yakunin is a massively corrupt official whose company oversaw a massively
corrupt Olympic railway project, and I’d never thought I’d say this, but I
agree with him.
On one
hand, yes, things are objectively dysfunctional and not ready despite the
fantastic sums spent, and there is objective photographic evidence of this. On
the other, as I prepare for my Moscow-Sochi flight tomorrow, a lot of this
complaining does smack of some pretty fantastic schadenfreude. From where I
sit—and, granted, I have yet to get to Sochi and encounter the shock of cold
water in the shower, and, granted, I’m a fine practicioner of mocking Russian
ridiculousness—it does seem like the Western press is on the hunt for evidence
of how inept and hilarious the Russians are. There does seem to be something
mean-spirited in all of this, as if the Western press came hoping to encounter pillow shortages and rusty water.
Again,
the evidence of failure is incontrovertible and embarrassing, but it is also, in
the scheme of things, minor. So far, nothing major has happened. Ski jumps have
yet to collapse, trains have yet to derail, there’s just some cold water and an
upside down toilet lid. It’s inconvenient and, yes, it’s funny, but here’s
where I agree with Yakunin: it’s the tone. There’s a fine line between fair
criticism and schadenfreude, and the Western press has been largely well on the
side of the latter. I’d also argue that there's something chauvinistic, even
Russophobic in it. The Europeans may not be ready for their Olympics, but,
okay, we’ll give them the benefit of the doubt and hope for the best. The
Chinese prepare for theirs ruthlessly, but we don’t understand them so
whatever. We railed on Romney for daring to criticize the preparedness of our
British friends, and we wrote in muted tones about Athens not being ready in
time for their Olympics, but with the Russians, we gloat: Look at these stupid
savages, they can’t do anything right.
Within
hours of arriving in Moscow yesterday, Russian friends, even the Westernized
ones, those who are openly, viciously critical of the Kremlin, have expressed their
hurt at the Western blooper coverage of Sochi. A whole lot of their tax money
has been spent on something they may not have wanted and in ways they find
criminally wasteful, and, yes, their government has not done much to endear
itself to the West of late, but they’re puzzled by why the Americans and the
British are so very happy that the details are a little screwy, the way they
generally are in Russia.
The
word they use is zloradstvo,
literally: evil-reveling.
I Want the Olympics to Succeed. On TV, the Opening Ceremony Did. By T.A. Frank. The New Republic, February 8, 2014.
In Praise of Sochi Schadenfreude. Here’s why we should celebrate Russia's failure. By David Harsanyi. The Federalist, February 7, 2014.
Harsanyi:
A few
months prior to the 2008 Summer Olympics games in Beijing, there was an Olympic
torch running ceremony in the Tibetan capital of Lhasa. There, the nation’s
Communist Party leader, Zhang
Qingli, declared that “China’s red flag with five stars will forever flutter
high above this land” before dropping a bit Jesse Myerson-ish rhetoric on
folks, explaining that China would “totally smash the splittist schemes of the
Dalai Lama clique.”
Qingli
saw the Olympics as optimal moment to launch into some political haranguing,
because the Olympics is a political event. Always has been. And sporadically,
regimes in various stages of authoritarianism, say the Nazis or the Chinese
Communists or the Russian Putinists, use this overhyped and overrated sporting
exhibition to try and convince others of the superiority of their regimes. This
is why the Germans made a spectacle in 1936, why the Soviets spent decades
trying to create Ivan Dragos — and also why, the 1980 United States ice hockey
victory over Soviet Union team was, for many of us, the greatest sports moment
of all time.
Here’s
how Charles Lane put it in a superb column detailing the uselessness of the
event:
Whatever
might be said for that idea in theory, it hasn’t panned out in practice. The
ostensibly apolitical Games have been marred by several boycotts — of Montreal
in 1976 (by African nations protesting apartheid), of Moscow in 1980 (by the
United States and other Western countries protesting the Soviet invasion of
Afghanistan) and of Los Angeles in 1984 (by communist countries retaliating for
1980).
The
Games also have created a target for extremists, from the Palestinian
terrorists who killed 11 Israeli athletes at Munich in 1972 to ultra-rightist
Eric Rudolph, who placed a deadly bomb at the 1996 Summer Games in Atlanta.
Consequently, these celebrations of international conviviality proceed under
heavy military guard.
On the
bright side, Sochi has been utter embarrassment for Vladimir Putin – or, in
other words, though it’s hardly started, it’s been the rare entertaining
Olympic experience. (update: Yes, this
includes opening ceremonies, with its Cirque du Soleil celebration of 20th-century
tyranny.)
We’ve
seen an avalanche of tweets from Western journalists about the crude amenities
in Sochi, the architectural challenges, the unfinished hotel rooms, the stray
dogs, the yellow drinking water, the garbage, not to mention the embargo of
imperialist Greek yogurt to American athletes.
Vladimir
Yakunin, a Russian plutocrat who, unlike some less vigilant magnates, knows
where his black bread is buttered, groused about Western journalists who were
“feeding hysteria about Russia.” Some people wondered if it was fair? Here’s
Julia Ioffe at the New Republic:
There’s
a fine line between fair criticism and schadenfreude, and the Western press has
been largely well on the side of the latter. I’d also argue that there’s
something chauvinistic, even Russophobic in it.
Russophobic?
As in harboring negative prejudices, dislikes and fears about Russia and
Russians? The place that gave us Dostoyevsky, Stravinsky, Solzhenitsyn and so
on and on and on . . . ? Hardly. Is it Russophobic to have a good laugh at the
expense of a crooked government that squanders an estimated $50 billion on a
publicity party when its per capita income is less than that of Equatorial
Guinea or Gabon? A country that is 140th in on the economic freedom index,
according to Heritage Foundation, slotted between Tajikistan and Burundi.
These
Olympics might even end up doing the Russians a favor by bringing attention to
their plight. Maybe Sochi will be seen as an event emblematic of the deeper
problems in the country, As Garry Kasparov puts it:
Do not
mistake the epic graft in Sochi as unusual or incidental. Corruption is the
overriding principle of Putin’s 14 years in power and looting the Russian
treasury and the Russian people is itself the goal. For all the foolish
attempts to interpret Putin’s geopolitical strategy and personal ideology, the
common denominator is always whether or not an action helps him maintain the
cash flow that in turn enables him and his clique to stay in power.
We
don’t even have to bring up the fact that Putin has consistently undermined
American interests, abetting brutal dictatorships in Syria and North Korea –
not to mention, shielding Iran’s nuclear ambitions. Surrounded by an army of
40,000 soldiers and police in a “ring of steel,” Bob Costas can whitewash his
host’s misdeeds, but Russia’s government is not only corrupt, and not only is
it intolerant of gays, but according to Amnesty International, human rights
violations by the government include killings, enforced disappearances and
torture, and they are “frequent.” According
to Freedom of Information index by Reporters Without Borders, Putin
belongs on a list with Chinese President Xi Jinping, North Korea’s Kim Jong-un,
Iran’s Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, the Italian Mafia and Chechnya’s Ramzan Kadyrov.
That’s
not to say that Russians, with or without Putin, don’t have a long way to go.
It’s not to say that the Russian people don’t have their quirks. But if Sochi
is, as Putin claims, a vision a “new Russia,” lots of people around the world
will see that the new Russia is extraordinarily similar to the old Russia.
This is
his Olympics. We should all get in a good laugh at his misfortune.
Sochi 2014 opening ceremony: Ernst delivers disco-led paean to the past. By Owen Gibson. The Guardian, February 7, 2014.
Gibson:
But
after all the talk of oppressive security, the disgrace of recently introduced
anti-gay laws, Russia’s human rights record and Putin’s macho shows of
strength, it was somehow refreshing that Konstantin Ernst chose to at least try to
highlight another side of the country’s character.
“I
wanted to present the history of Russia as seen though the eyes of a little
girl, who represents the feminine side of Russia,” he said. “The real Russians,
untainted by decades of propaganda and the cold war.” Malfunctioning snowflakes
aside, he largely succeeded.
Sochi’s Opening Ceremony Forgot to Mention a Few Things About Russian History. By Julia Ioffe. The New Republic, February 8, 2014.
Irina Rodnina, the Woman Lighting the Sochi Olympic Flame, Tweeted a Racist, Doctored Picture of President Obama. By Julia Ioffe. The New Republic, February 7, 2014.
Irina Rodnina, Former Russian Skater Who Lit Olympic Flame, Tweeted Racist Obama Photo. By Andrew Hart. The Huffington Post, February 7, 2014.
Russian MP Irina Rodnina’s Obama with banana picture sparks racism debate. By Shaun Walker. The Guardian, September 16, 2013.
Welcome to Sochi: Beware the Water. By Stacy St. Clair. NJBR, February 5, 2014.
