Lévy:
The “Gaza generation” seems worried about
Arab deaths only when Jews are involved.
About
the crowds on Friday in Paris chanting “Palestine will overcome” and “Israel,
assassin”: Where were they a few days earlier when news broke that over the
previous weekend Syria’s civil war had produced 720 more dead, adding to the
150,000 others who have not had the honor of demonstrations in France?
Why did
the protesters not pour into the streets when, a few days before that, the
well-informed Syrian Network for Human Rights revealed that so far this year
Damascus’s army, which was supposed to have destroyed its supply of chemical
weapons, carried out at least 17 gas attacks around Kafrzyta, Talmanas, Atshan
and elsewhere?
Will
these people, “outraged” for a day, claim that they did not know, that they saw
no images of the others who died, and that today only images have the power to
stir them to action? That is not going to work. Because they had seen what was
happening in Syria. As reporters later discovered, those same grisly images, or
older versions of them, were appropriated, doctored and retweeted by organizers
of the anti-Israel demonstrations under the dishonest hashtag GazaUnderAttack.
Will
the protesters claim that they were rallying against French President François
Hollande and a policy of unilateral support for Israel that they do not wish to
see conducted “in their name?” Perhaps. But conducting outward politics for
inner reasons—converting a large cause into a small instrument designed to
salve one’s conscience at little cost—reflects little genuine concern for the
fate of the victims. Even more pointedly, should not the same reasoning have
filled the same streets 10 or 100 times to protest the same president's
decision, likewise taken in their name, not to intervene in Syria?
Will
they say that it is Israel’s disproportion in force that is shocking, the
imbalance between an all-powerful army and defenseless civilians? That argument
has some merit, but in the end it also doesn’t hold up. For if that were the
reason for protests—if one were primarily concerned about the Palestinian
children whose deaths are indeed an abomination—one would demand that Hamas
operatives leave the hospital basements where they have buried their command
centers, move the rocket launchers that they have installed in the doorways of
United Nations schools, and stop threatening parents who wish to evacuate their
homes when an Israeli leaflet informs them that a strike is imminent.
Moreover,
if alarm about disproportion and asymmetry were the true wellspring of the
protesters’ rage, would they not have had at least a passing thought for
another disproportion that, not so far from Gaza, now afflicts the most
wretched of the wretched, the most defenseless of all, the Christians of Mosul?
Hamas’s “brothers” are offering these Iraqis the following ultimatum: Embrace
Islam or die by the sword.
The
truth is that these protesters—most of them young members of the
self-proclaimed “Gaza generation,” for whom the latest in chic is to sport a
kaffiyeh made in Palestine—assume it is normal for Arabs to kill other Arabs.
They
are also unperturbed upon learning, from the very mouth of the Hamas leadership
(Journal of Palestine Studies, Vol. 41, No. 4), that in 2012 alone the construction of the infamous Gaza tunnels
cost the lives of 160 Palestinian children who were turned into little slaves
and buried in the rubble.
The
oldest of these protesters also missed the chance to mobilize in favor of the
300,000 Darfurians massacred by Sudan; the 200,000 Chechens whom Putin, in his
own elegant phrase, “kicked into the crapper” not so long ago; and the Bosnians
who were besieged and bombarded to general indifference for three years. The
truth is that for these selectively conscientious objectors, indignation
arrives only when one has the opportunity to condemn a military consisting
mostly of Jews.
The
double standard is odious. And it has become increasingly evident across Europe
in the past month. Bluntly anti-Semitic slogans have marred most European
demonstrations “in support of the people of Gaza.” Residents of Frankfurt and
Dortmund were horrified in mid-July to see neo-Nazi groups join hands with
left-wing Islamists in a grim chant: “Hamas, Hamas, Jews to the gas.” The
center of London was blocked on July 19 by thousands who gathered in front of
the Israeli embassy in Kensington to shout their hatred for Jews.
Not to
mention Amsterdam, the city of Spinoza, Europe’s capital of tolerance, where in
certain neighborhoods it has become practically impossible to wear a yarmulke
in public without running the risk of being insulted or assaulted.
For
someone who has advocated, as I have, for nearly half a century the creation of
a Palestinian state alongside a fully recognized Israel, this is truly
discouraging. That there are sincere men and women among the demonstrators I do
not doubt. But I would urge them to think twice before letting themselves be
manipulated by those whose motive is not solidarity but hate, and whose true
agenda is not peace in Palestine but death to Israel—and, as often as not,
alas, death to Jews.
